October 2nd, 2008
New Scientist says the best sf film is Blade Runner. Runners up are 2001, Solaris, and Serenity. The worst? And other categories?
Worst sci-fi films:
The Blob, the 1958 sci-fi/horror film starring Steve McQueen. “I saw The Blob when I was about seven years old and haven’t eaten jelly since,” said one of our staff. Others noted that The Blob has one of the most implausible theme tunes of any sci-fi film.
Dune, the 1984 film directed by David Lynch, must rank as one of the most unsuccessful adaptations of all time, at least according to New Scientist staffers: the novel by Frank Herbert on which it was based was voted one of the best books in the in-house poll.
Most gratuitously scantily-clad female character:
The gold went to The Fifth Element‘s Leeloo, played by Milla Jovovitch, for her half-unwrapped-mummy outfit. Silver went to Jane Fonda’s Barbarella, heroine of the eponymous film รขโฌโ although one editor defended her negligible outfits: “Barbarella is actually about sex and love and all that, so it makes sense that she hardly wears anything.” Bronze went to Jeri Ryan, she of the nothing-to-the-imagination catsuit featured in Star Trek: Voyager.
Most incomprehensible:
Primer, the 2004 low-budget film directed by Shane Carruth. “Well worth watching,” said one of our editors, “though you might be excused for wondering if it makes any sense at all.”
Both ardently loved and fervently loathed:
The New Scientist staff are a contradictory bunch: Dune, The Matrix, Blade Runner and Event Horizon all featured on both the most loved and most hated lists.
They’ve got open voting for both films and books. Check it out and weigh in.
A few comments. I need to watch Primer again. I liked it, but was drinking and the ending got…confusing. I’m sure I can sort it out, but I should be totally sober at the time. I like a smart movie.
I also like a little cheesecake. Leeloo and Barbarella were sexy and had style.
I kind of like the Dune movie, too, if only for the look. The sandworms looked like sandworms.
I also love The Blob. When you see a movie when you’re eight or nine and love it, it’s hard to shake.
Myself and others have made posts about sf movies in the past. I have my lists of the best science-based sf movies, the worst movie, and then there are others, too. I have my own top ten list, and in that post I also summarize several others from the internet.
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
I’ve watched Primer three times. It’s a great film, and actually does make sense – if you’re pedantic enough to say, create a timeline for the film to follow [http://www.cs.montana.edu/~arnone/pics/primer_timeline.jpg].
Carruth did purposefully leave a scene missing from the film so you never have ‘quite’ the complete picture of events, which is one of the things that really made it excellent in my eyes.
When people ask me about great Sci-fi films, I always make sure to mention Contact and Primer for their *actual science*. Everything after that is of course aliens, guns and explosions.
The (original) Blob scared the heck out of me as a kid. I don’t care how “plausible” it is, it works, as a flick.
Unlike the remake, which was just (like so many other remakes) a SFX showcase that missed the point of the original.
(Which is why I’m not looking forward to the remake of another classic, The Day the Earth Stood Still!)
Well Fred, there’s the old saying that the golden age of science fiction is when you’re twelve. I remember vividly that old man with the blob on his arm and how scary it was as it started to consume him. Totally chilling.
Tucker, I’d add 2001 to that very short list of Contact and Primer.
Actually it was more like five. By the time I was twelve, I was reading “Chip” Delany, Gene Wolfe and a lot of other stuff that twisted my mentality!
God knows what I’ll be reading next year. Maybe some Hard SF by some guy named Mike?
Definitely be reading some hard sf by guys named Mike, please!
I know have a book by some hard SF guy named Mike in hand and another on order. What we need is more books by a hard SF guy named Mike!
๐
Great! And I know! It’s too slow…