June 3rd, 2009
I had meant to link to physicist Sean Carroll’s excellent Rules for Time Travelers that he posted a couple of weeks ago. Sean is a world expert on time and knows his stuff. Awesome post.
I made a very similar post last year called Science and Science Fiction: Time Travel. A lot of the basic issues and complaints are the same as Sean’s, which makes me feel good (I’m an astrophysicist but far from a “world expert on time”). I think his article is a little clearer and direct, although we do talk about some different things and provide some different resources.
I have complained many times about time travel handled badly in science fiction, and expect I will continue to do so. Maybe if there are more complaints about the ridiculousness of the time travel in things like Heroes and Back to the Future, they’ll happen a little less often and be a little less appreciated, and eventually, in the distant future, let movies and TV evolve into something smarter.
Sorry, I think I slipped from science fiction into fantasy with that last bit above…but we can travel into the future together, one second per second, and see!
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
Sean does pretty good in that article but totally dropped the ball on the latest “New Rules for Time Travelers” being hyped by Discover. I saw this paper on it by an engineer, Marshall Barnes, that was probably the best thing I’ve read about a time travel subject. Carroll has nothing on this guy. He’s talking physics and not sci fi, but many of the issues you complain about in stories would seem to irk Marshall as well. The detail that he put into the article about Sean using a time gate to create a CTC, borders on brilliant. You have to read it to believe so I suggest you do that and form your own opinion.
Ooops! I forgot to provide the links.
Here’s the one to Sean’s new article – http://discovermagazine.com/2010/mar/02-the-real-rules-for-time-travelers
Here’s the one to Marshall’s paper – http://www.scientificblogging.com/temporal_mechanic/blog/“new_rules_time_travel_â€_and_sean_carroll’s_gate_2
Enjoy!
Thanks for the links. I’ll check them out soon. Sounds very nice!