February 2nd, 2010
There’s an article about artificial limbs with a picture of an attractive woman, a double-amputee, running along the beach. The premise of the article is that some artificial limbs are starting to outperform original limbs, in at least some ways. This trend will continue into the future, no doubt, until we have the capability to make impressive cyborgs. I’m just wondering how many people, if anyone, even among science fiction loving folks who are the most common readers here, would cut off a healthy limb in favor of a mechanical limb that worked better. (I understand “better” is a relative term here, probably.) If I had a permanently injured limb, for sure, probably. But a normal healthy limb?
What do you think?
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
seriously, I doubt mechanical limbs and organs will exist much longer… the Star Wars robotic hand of Luke Skywalker for example, probably will never come to exist, because we are perfecting ORGANIC limb and organ replacements, made out of stem cells, etc.
Want to improve something? Not only we will have genetic treatments, as probably nanobots in our blood vessels (the nanobots will make us cyborgs, thats true).
I think we can improve every aspect of our body simply by messing with genetics. (and the same way, we will be able to uplift other animals).
And when organs or limbs start failing or you lose them, make a new one that IS your (made from your own cells).
I think we will have mechanical components only for a few things that may be impossible to make organic.
Gee, I think your own book, Star Dragon, dealt with this issue in some depth, didnt it?
In the real world, there is too much uncertainty and risk with medical technology anyway for me to consider intentionally replacing a limb with a supposedly better prosthetic version.
E.g. recently I’ve seen articles about how laser eye surgery (which seems to have become fairly mainstream) is causing a lot more long term problems than people were led to believe.
I agree with Russ, there is too much uncertainty to consider it. I like my legs. Plus there is always the troubling issue of continued upgrades and maintenance. And who is going to write the software in control of this limb. I know too many crappy programmers (admittedly I live in Redmond, WA).
Well, we are cyborgs already, many of us. Just not by choice. I mean, glasses, false teeth, hip and joint replacements…and limbs for amputees.
Yes, Star Dragon is all bio. I agree with you, Rogerio, that it will be this way in the far far future, maybe probably, if we get there with high tech. Unless we decide something else is better. Near term (decades still probably) we’re talking mechanical replacements.
Mike, do you really think it will take so much time for all this kind of bio replacements/improvements? Well, maybe not like in Star Dragon, but like I talked about… the medical scientists hint that all of this AND immortality are closer than we may imagine…
Probably. This stuff takes longer than people think, in the short-term. Closer than the average person imagines is still decades, or even centuries. Medicine/health doesn’t have the speeds of computers (of course the marriage of the two is the great hope).
If I was some kind of mercenary, maybe I would upgrade my arm to a titanium limb or rotating mini Gatling.
[…] positioned. In fact, they are developing a contact lens that will have this very capability. The poll that was set forward was about replacing perfectly healthy limbs for the bionic ones and would you […]
[…] vous êtes placés. En fait, ils développent un verre de contact qui aura cette même capacité. Le sondage qui a été avancé s’est agi de remplacer des membres tout à fait en bonne santé pour les […]
[…] Tatsächlich entwickeln sie eine Kontaktlinse, die diese wirkliche Fähigkeit haben wird. Die Wahl, die hervorgebracht wurde, war über das Ersetzen vollkommen gesunder Glieder für die bionischen […]
[…] positioned. In fact, they are developing a contact lens that will have this very capability. The poll that was set forward was about replacing perfectly healthy limbs for the bionic ones and would you […]