December 20th, 2009
Now, I don’t expect everyone to love everything that I love, but I do know that everyone loves the results of science even if they don’t readily acknowledge it. I mean, people love using the internet, driving cars, being warm in the winter, getting medicine when they are sick, all that good stuff. But even if they don’t readilly acknowledge this love for the roots of science, I do understand the hate. Or I think I do, part of it.
I’ve taught science to non-major students a number of years and also spend my time watching science wars on the internet (e.g., deniers of global warming, evolution, etc.).
I think that countering biases means figuring out misconceptions, confronting them, and knocking them down first thing. If you don’t hit the misconception, you don’t actually teach anyone anything. The misconceptions run strong and reassert themselves over time. So, I want to try to list the issues people have with science, rational and irrational, and want to think about how to respond to and perhaps counter these.
1. Scientists are arrogant, so I don’t like science.
Bush and Clinton are arrogant, so does that mean you don’t like politics? Simon Cowell on American Idol is arrogant, but he is popular and tens of millions of peolple like that show. Astronomers Neil DeGrasse Tyson and Carl Sagan don’t come across as arrogant on their TV shows, so maybe everyone can like some science.
2. Science is full of math. I’m not good at math, so I don’t like science.
Not all sciences have a lot of math (e.g., biology). Moreover, science concepts are more fundamental than the math. The science is all in setting up the equations. The math is in solving them, so you can understand the science without the math. (P.S. Math isn’t so bad, really!)
3. Science is full of negativity. Scientists are always doubting things. It isn’t just arrogance, it’s being pessimistic, skeptical doubters. So I don’t like science.
This is true, but necessary. Sometimes it’s better to have a dose of honesty, and not take everything on authority. Besides, not every idea is right out there, so let’s make a virtue out of honesty, ok?
4. My beliefs are strong, and I have faith. Science says some things contradictory to my beliefs (e.g. evolution, global warming, autism, etc.), so I don’t like science.
Well, this one is harder I think. Reality is reality. Science doesn’t care. We can be understanding about people in the past, with a different culture and educational background interpreting things as they saw them. We know better now. And science, ultimately, is less beholden to any particular belief system or ideology. Eventually it gets to the right answer, like it or not, and there’s always someone one your side and on the other side who both get bitten by science. Science is not a belief system. It reflects reality. We all have to deal with reality, don’t we?
5. Science is mechanistic and cold, so I don’t like it.
Think of your favorite robot. The Iron Giant. Bender. Data. Robby. R2-D2. HAL. Okay, maybe not HAL. But there’s at least one robot out there you like, isn’t there? Make that the face of cold, mechanical science, if you must.
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
Actually, biology has a tremendous amount of math, primarily statistics.
Yes, you’re right about that of course. And it doesn’t matter if it isn’t calculus, it’s still very scary to the mathphobic. There are subfields of many sciences where math isn’t omnipresent — they’re just getting harder to think of!
don’t like “science”?
ok. live without it and its benefits for one day – I dare ya!
I suck at match. Thats why I havent become a scientist. But it never made me not LOVE science
actually, there are so many scientists who wrote GREAT BOOKS explaining science with great concepts, without any mathematics, that its quite weird that there are people capable of disliking science because of such thing.
IMHO, the number 1 reason people dislike science its because it PROVES THEM WRONG.
Meaning, they love science when it creates gadgets for them (they dont even aknowledge it as science), but as soon as you question them about some of their unscientific beliefs, they are ready to bash science.
So much of the “I don’t like it” attitude can also be changed by a good instructor. An experience can vary so much within the same subject depending on the enthusiasm and competence of the teacher/professor. Even if the students don’t know the subject well, they can tell if their teacher knows what their doing. This comment is not limited to science. I should also add that some brilliant people in their field should not be in a traditional classroom setting. I think your classes would be interesting and fun!
oops – “what they’re doing”
Jessica, I certainly had that experience (good vs. bad teacher) at JBS with history and English. I’ll let you guess who was who there…
[…] perks of publication. Juno Books on Book Sales Stats: Apples and Oranges? Mike Brotherton on Five Reasons Why People Think They Hate Science (and what to do about it!). Kate Elliott on When What We Think We Know, Is Actually Wrong. Janice Hardy on Great Holiday Gifts […]
[…] Brotherton explains Five Reasons Why People Think They Hate Science and what to do about it. (Other than just kicking their […]
I just wanna post one comment. When you say “Science is not a belief system. It reflects reality.”, BE CAREFUL. As a chemistry teacher, I must say that science does NOT represent the truth, but gives another point of view of what goes around us. Nowadays, it’s the most accepted view, but being it constructed over models, it’s not really the truth. Actually, it IS a belief system, whose structure is a bit off of what we are used to. There is no truth. There are ways of seeing it. I like the metaphore of Pozo (spanish educator), when he says science is like a binch of blind people trying to tell how an ellephant is by touch: some will focus on the pawn, others on the nose, and so one, and no one will get the whole picture.
Reality sucks!That’s why everyone hates science!Damned laws like “oh,you can’t jump off a 900,000 feet cliff sailor diving and live pfft!Utter nonsense.Lol.My sister was just yelling that at me.
Cool, I love it when people put science in a good light. I’m currently reading Carl Sagan’s The Demon Haunted World, which is fantastic and I recommend the book to everyone.
@ Vitor
I disagree. Science of course does not represent the truth, and yes, it is just another point of view.
However, it is at this moment, THE BEST point of view. It makes more predictions and does its absolute best to provide evidence (and it does) for such claims, more than any other “point of view” on our planet. If science has value then it has some truth to it.
As a former student and a current teacher in a homeschool, I think you missed the main reason science is boring to so many of us: the way it’s taught. For the most part, it is taught with textbooks and tests, requiring memorization of vocabulary and concepts that often seem to have no meaning or purpose for the student. If science could be taught by actually letting the students DO science–e. g., work in a lab, or work on an actual field study–I think more of us would like it. Experiments in class don’t quite cut it, though they help. My .02.
I can do math as in algebra, alegebra II (not geometry, I hate shapes). But when you mix the idea of math with science I just can’t do it at all. mixing equations I have never done before with a bunch of complex big words with even more complex definitions just makes my brain shut down
Most of what you put on your list I have never heard anyone say. In fact what I hear people say about why they hate science is mostly the same thing I say:
1. science is not important to my major (I am planning to teach history, not science so I don’t like wasting money and time on classes I don’t actually need and will more than likely forget by the time second semester starts)
2. it is too textbook and lecture based. If science were more hands on from the time of elementary all the way through high school (and college if it must be taken at the college level) people wouldn’t hate it so much. also I hated it whenever teachers got to do the experiment but never let us get to do anything except watch it. it was always the suckiest “experiments” that no one wanted to do that was hands on in my h.s. chem class.
3. standardized testing just ruins whatever fun you could possibly learn from science. too many of my teachers teach from the test.
4. It just isn’t visual enough. Math and science need to be very visual and very example based but for some reason it is not.
Now I know science is important, but that is why there are people that choose to go into those careers. I just can’t stand that I have to pay and waste my time to take a class that I am not going to remember by the end of winter break (lets face it, none of us actually process and comprehend we just memorize long enough to meet the upcoming goal).
i think it depends on weather the teacher engage withe the class and uses good anologies aswell as fun experiments.
Science sucks and it is boring and I am doing a science project on thanksgiving break and I can’t finisH it cause I don’t have enough information to write a six page report on natural gas!
I googled “I hate science” and this website popped up,!
I know i’m weird!!!!!!!!!!!!! 😉
Lexie you rock!!!!! I love you!!!! This is like Facebook, we can talk about how stupid science is!!!!!
I don’t care what scientist say!!!! SCIENCE IS STUPID!!!!!!
Lexie, Ashlee, and Kelly are dead wrong. Science is a beautiful thing and we all can learn and grow on it!!!
Are u a scientist?
That is none of your business! You are just saying you hate science because you are lazy!!! Your computer is an example of science!! Your phone is an example of science!! Your TV is an example of science!! So is your shower, your iPod, your Radio, and your car!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Come on Lexie, let’s get on Facebook, it’s a million times better than this stupid website!!!!!!!!!!!!
THIS WEBSITE SUCKS!!!!!!
I hate math, but I LOOOVE science, robots, science fiction, anything science I truly enjoy.
Science makes life so easy because of that it caused more painful things. it gives car and it gives carbondioxide gas. it gives light, electricity and it gives global warming. ha ha ha
it gives chemistry and it gives desease. it gives knowledgeble people rich and other people are poor.
Science was So hard for me to understand when I was young because I had a poor teacher so after I finally figured out how great science is I became a science teacher at vale middle school and it is the best thing that has ever happened to me!! If you love science and children become a science teacher. It’s amazing how many lives change because of teachers!!!!!!!
Oh Burst I love what you wrote! It’s exactly how I feel! Science is 100x better than math!!!!! <3
Science is super cool when the experiments rock!!! Today in science we did a cool experiment with an egg and vinegar and syrup!!!! Science is cool if you give it a chance!!!
Don’t abuse this website, people. Its good!
I hate science because no matter how much I try to work on it, I always don’t fully understand it or just do it all wrong. And I never know what I’ve done wrong.
I hate it so much.
I appreciate science, I really do. I’m not even bad at it (undergrad in neuroscience), BUT I do have a problem with the way science is taught in schools. I find that there is very little inquiring done by students. Science becomes something machine like, not dynamic, not something that requires deep thinking. I’d say at least 60% of the kids I go to to uni with don’t have a clue what is happening, or can’t think for themselves, or can’t communicate their answers. Kids who do just great on multiple choice questions. All the while arts students are encouraged to think critically…and there is no such thing as all answers are right answers in the arts. I’d like to see more science students take up subjects like English, politics, philosophy, linguistics…instead of being restricted mainly to chemistry, physics, biology. See it too often
I think its because kids (like me) absolutely hate school with a passion, and think it’s a waste of time.
As far as evolution goes, I disagree with it. I don’t think there is concrete evidence to support such a claim. Nevertheless I am a biology major in college and have my ups and downs in terms of grades.
I love and I am good at art, poetry, literature, languages, history. But I deeply hate science and the way it is taught at school. And yes, most of the science teachers are very arrogant and contemptuous. My worst nightmare at school!
But HAL was my favorite robot…
I don’t think anyone should be forced to like/dislike science. Although, they should be told to respect science’s verdict and science: vice versa. As for me…That’s none of your buisness. Other than that, everyone should just keep an open mind and take a chance with science, or whatever you presently struggle to accept/learn.
I like science, personally. It doesn’t just give a statement. it backs it up too.
The_Thinker, I’m mostly concerned that it’s important for people to know something about science and understand it at some level. If they hate it, well, they’re going to be less likely to learn anything about it.
Everyone takes advantage of inventions brought about through discovery, but that doesn’t mean some of us can’t think science is empty and boring. I like science, I hate the WORSHIP of science. Yet I feel forced to worship it, because of its results. I hate it. I dread it. It’s empty, and science can’t love me.
Todd, change your mind. I see essentially no one “worshiping” science. It’s just that most knowledge is based on science or opinion, and as someone with intellectual honesty, I prefer science. Push that idea, without the need for worship. Just because something works doesn’t mean people need to worship it. Science is a passionless, impartial institute and does not care about worship. STOP IT! 😉
I don’t hate science. I fear science. Science is a logical way of explaining things, but it is scary how it says that humanity will stop existing. Science is supposed to be truth and sometimes the truth is harsh. I would like to think that the universe doesn’t exist so it never ends because it never started. Science always disproves itself and I would like to think that there is no definite answer, but school doesn’t teach that.
I hate science, but what I hate more is when people mix two things that have nothing to do with each other. It’s like when a liberal says to a conservative (in the USA)that ‘the entire country is founded on a liberal idea and that you have what you have because of liberals, so saying that you are a conservative goes against your country’–conservatives are the way they are because they believe certain ways on issues and belive that you deserve to keep the money that you earn instead of give it to lazy welfare receivers.
You say that science is technology, and though technology stems in some way from science, the inventors most likely did not even think about chemistry, biology, or physics when creating a cell phone, or a computer. When you think of it your way, you might as well say that everything has to do with science, but even though that is true, that isn’t what people mean by ‘hating science’. What most people hate is the math and the memorization part of it.
Personally, I am great at math, it’s my favorite subject in school. I used to get so confused when people responded to me–after I told them that I hate science–by saying that that doesn’t make sense because I like math. To me, they are completely different things. I don’t understand half of what is taught in science classes but understand math completely. Hey, maybe I’m just weird, but I think it has to do with subject, not how it is taught. For some reason, I just cannot stand it; I cannot remember any of the definitions or equations–and I tried, believe you me–and science still continues to kick my you-know-what to this day. I can’t seem to memorize any of it as if my mind filters out unimportant stuff and science some how gets mislabled.
If someone could explain this to, me I would be grateful. I like the idea of being able to back things up with logical explanations, but the class–forget about it! I hate all of it.
Gee, thanks. That was so…… completely wrong. I still hate science because as boring and dumb as watching a constipated dog try to poop.
Hi my friend! I want to say that this article is amazing, nice written and come with almost all significant infos. I’d like to see more posts like this .
I personally seem to agree with the whole thing that is written in “Five Reasons Why
People Think They Hate Science (and what to do about it!
)”. I am grateful for all of the actual advice.
Regards,Shaun
I love science, science is great. How do you function without the science in the society? However I absolutely hate the arrogance of the irrational skeptics and people who use science to shield themselves to look bigger than they are. People who are closed minded who hides behind the veneer of science. They think their brain is of the highest order, and that the whole world is under their theories and egotistical talks. Science is but a progress towards finding the truth, but not the final truth itself, so quit being arrogant.
I don’t like science because it doesn’t interest me. I think physics is too reliant on math, I don’t like biology because it (I’ll be honest here) creeps me out, and I don’t like psychology because I don’t really like people and don’t want to know how they think. People are less shallow than the way you make them seem in here.
These aren’t accurate. I don’t like science because it’s boring, and most of the stuff that’s taught doesn’t help me with life in the future in anyway unless i WANTED to become a scientist. Why should I give a damn about a “golgi body”? What if I simply don’t care, and am not curious? What if I LIKE to not know so I can put it to my imagination? Also, scientists just arent fun people. This is why I think the creative, fun type do not like science
Science don’t have a lot of math (Biology). That’s a lie because Biology degree requires lots of chemistry and math courses (Calculus 2).
You forgot one big reason: “Science is a horrible career choice. You study very hard, the competition is high, the pay is low and there is almost no job security. So I hate it and encourage others to hate it, too. “